The real Dune

18,487,631
3,615
2022-05-22に共有
What is the real story of Dune in the original book, compared to the 2021 Dune movie?
Dune Sequels Explained:    • Dune Sequels Explained  
Dune podcast w/ Quinn:    • Dune with Quinn's Ideas  
Dune Q&A livestream:    • Dune Q&A  
Alt Schwift X Dune rap:    • Dune rap  

Audible: www.audible.com/asx

Subscribe:    / @altshiftx  
Support on Patreon: www.patreon.com/AltShiftX
Twitter: twitter.com/altshiftx

Podcast: art19.com/shows/alt-shift-x-podcast
Audio feed: anchor.fm/alt-shift-zzz

This video has spoilers for the 2021 Dune movie and the first half of the first Dune book.
It has no big spoilers for the sequel books or future movies – just some minor lore details and quotes.

Images and video from Dune used under fair use. Clips from Dune (2021) movie, Dune (1984) movie, Dune (2000) miniseries, Jodorowsky's Dune (2013).
Dune graphic novel art by Raúl Allén & Patricia Martín
Dune: House Atreides graphic novel art by Dev Pramanik
Thumbnail Paul art by Bella Bergolts: www.artstation.com/bergolts
Art by Aurélien Police: www.aurelienpolice.com/
Art by Rostyslav Zagornov: www.artstation.com/attemme
Art by Lucas Staniec: www.artstation.com/lucasstaniec
Art from Dune: Adventures in the Imperium: www.modiphius.net/pages/discover-dune-roleplaying-…
Art by Stephen Youll: stephenyoull.com/
Art by Deak Ferrand / RODEOFX: www.artstation.com/deakferrand
Art by Ramazan Kazaliev: www.artstation.com/ramazan221
Art by Jenny Frison: jennyfrison.com/
Art by Anna Butova: www.artstation.com/annabutova
Art by Peter König: www.artstation.com/peterkonig
Art by Denis Maznev: www.instagram.com/denismaznev.art/
Art by Louis Accard: www.artstation.com/louisaccard
Art by Anato Finnstark: www.artstation.com/anto-finnstark
Art by Even Amundsen: www.artstation.com/mischeviouslittleelf
Art by Marcin Basta: www.artstation.com/bastamarcin
Art by Sparth: www.artstation.com/sparth
Kazoo Kid remix by Mike Diva:    • Kazoo Kid - Trap Remix  
Art by Eren ARIK: www.artstation.com/erenarik
Art by Mark Molnar: www.artstation.com/markmolnar
Art by Dmitry Andreev: www.artstation.com/di-shiper
Art by Finnian MacManus: www.artstation.com/fmacmanus
Crysknife art by SomethingWorkshop: cults3d.com/en/3d-model/art/dune-movie-2021-cryskn…
Art by Hlblng: www.instagram.com/Hlblng/
Art by Keith Christensen: www.artstation.com/keithchristensen
Art by Logan Feliciano: www.artstation.com/loganfeliciano
Art by Marc Simonetti: art.marcsimonetti.com/
Art by Michael Soong: michaelsoong.com/
Art by Cossim: www.deviantart.com/cossim
Art by Ron Miller
Art by Terry Oakes: www.facebook.com/terryoakesofficial/
Art by Peter Popken: www.artstation.com/gambit
Art by Mike Szabados: www.artstation.com/mikeszabados
Art by jontorresart: www.deviantart.com/jontorresart
Art by Alex Jay Brady: www.artstation.com/boac
Art by Jordan Lamarre-Wan: www.artstation.com/jroid

References & further reading:
Frank Herbert interview with Willis E. McNelly, 1969:    • Frank Herbert on the origins of Dune ...  
Frank Herbert interview with Jim Freund, 1976: archive.org/details/WBAI_99_5_FM_20211016_100000 and archive.org/details/WBAI_99_5_FM_20211023_100000
Frank Herbert interview with Mother Earth News, 1981: www.motherearthnews.com/nature-and-environment/fra…
Frank Herbert interview with Jean Marie Stine, 1984: futurespast-editions.blogspot.com/2013/10/lost-int…
Frank Herbert at UCLA, 1985:    • Frank Herbert speaking at UCLA 4/17/1985  
The Maker of Dune by Frank Herbert and Tim O’Reilly (1987)
Dreamer of Dune by Brian Herbert (2003)
Haris A. Durrani on Arabic and Islam in Dune: hdernity.medium.com/revisiting-dune-table-of-conte…

Special thanks to Patrons Cameron Weiss, Michael Appell, Ryan Steele, Harry, Shane Veglia, NotGac, Tim Cunniff, T. Ledoux, Ilhuilkamina Urdiana.

0:00 Dune
1:38 Imperium
5:32 Bene Gesserit
06:38 Spice
08:09 Harkonnens
10:20 Atreides
11:14 Sardaukar
11:52 Paul
13:09 Leto & the bull
15:32 Gom jabbar
17:49 Kwisatz Haderach
20:46 Gurney Halleck
21:53 Shields
22:46 Duncan Idaho
23:51 Caladan
24:44 Lisan al-Gaib
25:55 Fremen mysteries
26:59 Mapes
28:47 Hunter-seeker
29:26 Conservatory
31:00 Traitor
31:48 Leto’s doom
32:37 Stilgar
34:45 Liet-Kynes
37:21 Harvester
39:07 Dinner party
43:46 Divisions
45:46 Yueh
49:06 Harkonnen attack
58:17 Paul’s visions
1:01:41 Kynes’ death
1:06:59 Storm
1:09:56 Desert
1:12:55 Fremen
1:22:40 The beginning

#Dune

コメント (21)
  • As someone who finally is deciding to get into Dune, it’s really weird realizing that “oh… everybody in all of fiction stole from this” even more than LOTR it feels like
  • "Game of thrones, in space, on drugs" is such a formidable pitch: it sounds so 60s yet Dune talks about such fundamentally human topics it manages to be timeless
  • 38:30 small correction: Leto spots the worm first, there is a bounty on spotting worms that Leto therefore deserves. He gives that bouty to the workers.
  • When can we expect a video on Dune part 2? This video was so great. It provided so much insight to the movie without having to read the book! Thank you!!!
  • @xttx7190
    The name Harkonnen comes from a Finnish surname Härkönen which comes from the word härkä meaning bull. So in a way Paul is also fighting a bull
  • Alt Shift X releasing 86 minutes of analysis on Dune. Bless the Maker and His water.
  • Is there a second one like this explaining the second movie yet? This was really well done.
  • I'm praying Alt Shift X will make the companion video of Dune part 2 soon!
  • @Banuna
    First of all, cheers to you for citing evidence via quotes for almost every claim you make. That must have been time consuming and annoying but boy does it add a lot to the video. Also, the visual aids were so incredibly helpful for a person who hasn’t read the books (like me). Without them, I would have gotten confused with all the names, plot lines, and locations. Amazing video, keep up the stellar work!!
  • Didn't realize how much deeper the Dune universe is than how the movie portrays. Incredible.
  • @JohnLogan3
    20 mins in and realized the explanation video is almost as long as the movie lol. Great breakdown! Needed all of this.
  • It's just been 20 mins of watching and I am so moved by the beautiful way in which you have discussed the entire learning that comes from this piece of art.... hats off to your work
  • @boggo3848
    Summarizing Dune in this format really reveals how insanely creative Frank Hebert was.
  • @RickleVR
    Its surreal that I've been subbed to you since 2015 from watching the Game of Thrones lore videos. Now in 2022, still following you for more lore videos on different media that I love. Thank you and keep up the amazing work as always!
  • Love to see dune getting this recognition and to see people talking about how dune is the predecessor and the inspiration for what we love about modern writing and film. I read it a couple years ago because my dad has been all over it since he was a kid. Love it yall!
  • @Yaggadin
    Man, this story is so well told, vizualized and structured. Thank you so much for making it easier to get into the series :)
  • The film really needed a scene where they explained the importance of Mentats in a society where thinking machines are illegal, and reveal to Paul that he has what it takes to become a Mentant himself.
  • I feel like Leto and Jessica are one the deepest, most tragic love stories you could ever read. It's not about two people who sacrificed everything for their love, but rather of two people who sacrificed their love for the greater good, because they knew that in the grand scheme of things, their relationship was not important to anyone but them. They would never give up their duties just to be together, because they know that that is not what the other one would have wanted. I think this is a much deeper and much more selfless form of love, one that makes me shed a tear every time I read this book.
  • I can confidently say this is the first YouTube video over an hour that I’ve not only watched the entire way through but went back when I wasn’t confident in my understanding of this story and your explanation of it, truly a masterpiece of the internet