WHAT IF Yoshikage Kira Won in Diamond is Unbreakable?

Shigechi: Is that a real hand? Kira: No. Part 4 ends

I think what's interesting about Kira winning, is the consequences because he indirectly prevents the world from being reset by Pucci. Because if Kira kills Jotaro. Then Pucci loses all the knowledge he needs to start Dio's ritual. So Pucci would effectively spend the rest of his life in depression because he wouldn't be able to accomplish his goals without Jotaro's memories.

Imagine polnareff goes to morioh because he finds out someone killed jotaro and wants to avenge him but since kira won its exceedingly hard to impossible to find where he is. Polnareff would aimlessly wander around trying to claim vengeance but then realizing the hopelessness of the situation falls down to his knees angry and sad that he couldnt find his friends killer. But then, in that moment the arrow pierces his body with the intent to make his wish into reality. Now thats a storyline id like to see.

I feel the best ending for kira is him to literally just open up to shinobu. She wanted more action in her relationship with kosawku. All it would take would her trying to spice things up romantically and kira opening up about his “desires.” They become a freaky little couple and then boom, no more murder. He takes his desires out on shinobu (in a healthy way). If he does this before hiyato finds out, he could have literally just actually formed a relationship with the kid and he wouldn’t have had him trying to snoop.

If you think about it, Kira winning would actively screw over Pucci since there’s no more Jotaro that he can memory disc in order to read DIO’s diary and attain heaven.

It would have been wonderful.

The idea of Polnareff going to Japan to defeat Kira is very amusing. Especially since it would develop a theme of him having to hunt for people with weird attributes regarding hands in an attempt to avenge someone close to him lmao.

Remember that they had Remi there who was able to tell if someone was killed by Kira. Not only that but she could somewhat "sense" him. Idk if that was just plot but she points out his new face (and Hiato) when she saw their photos. She didn't say "oh that's him" but more like "these stand out". Kira also seems to have a bit of an ego and want's people to know about him and the murders even if he says he doesn't.

My personal favorite case scenario is the prisoner of love. It holds a bit of a positive ending considering that things play out right, nobody else has to die. The bite the dust ending is honestly the most likely cast scenario to happen if I’m being honest. Dude seriously fumbled the bag by not turning off the loop after he dusted the Jostars the first time.

I love how I went into this knowing exactly what was going to happen and just being like "Yeah, he just wants to kill people every once in a while" but what I did not expect was playing into his family life and being totally normal with Hayato being just a weirdo

Morioh is a great town, but the fact that it had four different serial killers over the course of a single summer (Angelo, Keicho, Akira, and Kira) makes it a lot worse sadly.

As the best villain in all of jojo, i can confirm that if kira won, he would most likely not take kosaku's life as kira would win. So no identities would be stolen, and he would kill but live a quiet life at the same time

what if kira didn’t have the biggest ego towards anything, actually had real combat skills and not running skills, and was probably like 10% smarter with the usage of his abilities/brain

WHAT IF Yoshikage Kira Had A Foot Fetish Instead?

What if Hiato said who Kira is on the radio. Would that just kill everyone in Morioh? That would surely lead to Kira getting caught as there would be investigations on why the whole town disappeared

personally, i like 3.5 because its kinda wholesome. Kira gets trapped in love, which causes him to lose the need to kill the Morioh warriors just wouldnt need to follow him anymore because they have no idea who he is and hes not killing anyone anymore so overall, its kinda just good for all of them

What if the events in part 7 and 8 happened in the original universe at the designated times that they were set, i think this would be an very interesting idea to theorise.

Maybe part of the reason Kira kinda had feelings for Shinobu is because of the "body," or at least face of Kosaku. Similar to how Jonathan's body still had some lingering control in competition with DIO when he took it over. This is extremely unlikely, but it was just an interesting thought I had.

If Kira beats Jotaro then the universe never gets reset cuz Pucci never gets his memories.

The speed wagon foundation getting involved would be very interesting. Perhaps Jolyne when she is grown up (before being framed and put in jail) goes to Morio to find who killed her father, attracting Kira b/c of her hands to herself. And Pucci is sad now since he has to find an alternate way for the Heaven Plan to work. Perhaps Limp Biscuit can revive Dio consciousness from the bone. Or Pucci stalks Jolyne to Morio and find that Crazy Diamond is a thing and tries to steal the stand to revive Dio's bone so he can learn what was in the Diary form Dio himself. Or he sees Hermit Purple exists and wants to test the stand to see if it can extract the info he wants in a janky way.