All Minecraft Life-series members RANKED - Who is the best?

Sorry about that, I had to reupload because of copyright stuff. Anyways, how would YOU rank the members? And where would you put yourself if you played?

Joel and Etho were so powerful in double life because Joel is crazy and Etho balanced him out with the logic and cautiousness. If Joel cared loads about self-preservation on the series he could be top 5 on here, but I love how he makes terrible decisions as it makes his videos extra funny

Joel should have been at a better spot on the list: If I remember correctly, Joel somehow managed to stay alive for 7 sessions as a red name in last life. Which takes some skill

I think saying "joel isnt horrible at pvp" doesnt give him the credit he deserves" joel is the best at pvp on the server and he could take any other member in a 1v1. If he cared about self preservasion like scott and martain do he would come a lot higher. Like in last life he came 5th and in ddouble life he came 4th. Joel is a pro

I feel like Scar was placed too low and BigB was placed too high. Scar had some of the most insane plays of the Life series (killing Ren & Martyn, starting session 5 of LL with 7 lives, the water bucket clutch, being the last green, being the first to kill 5 people in a single session...) and even though he does die a lot, his good plays make up for it. BigB on the other hand, like you said, is good at bystanding. The rest? Not so much. The only reason he was the last green in Third Life is because he missed a session.

I think Joel and Scott are the 2 best players in terms of PvP, which might be why Joel tends to target Scott so often. Joel overall is more reckless compared to Scott's very cautious nature. Im not complaining though, Joel's content is always hilarious.

I think you may be giving Etho and Ren slightly too much credit (though I do also somewhat appreciate you putting them so high, because a lot of people actually underrate them!), and Pearl and Joel FAR too little credit. Joel is arguably the best pvper, though I understand that's not all that contributes to this list, and he has made some pretty stupid plays... But Pearl I think you just underrate in general. She's an excellent survivalist and has the highest average placement for a reason, and she's one of the best pvpers too (only beaten by the obvious three, being Scott Martyn and Joel)! Overall I'd bump her up to 3rd, but that's just my opinion!

I feel like Pearl deserves higher. She's been top 4 every time since her introduction! (Alongside Scott and Martyn, actually. Since Last Life top 4 has been those three and someone "random")

I didn't expect Etho to be that high! I honestly thought Pearl would've ranked higher than Etho, as she has survived longer than him in all of the series she has participated in. I can see how because of Etho's encyclopedic minecraft knowledge, as well as his ability to create simple farms for short series, why he is placed so high. He has been placing moderately high since last life, and though people say he dropped off in limited life, Etho outlived many people who had more time than him during the final session, as he consistently got kills. I think he proves to be one of the best teammates to have for sure.

Scar should be higher imo. Sure he's clumsy BUT he's fantastic at using his charm to get him out of as many situations as gets him into, getting other Lifers to do his bidding and playing both sides. You never quite know where you stand with Scar which means you constantly have to be on your game. Mumbo should be lower than Scar at the very least, but I also think if Mumbo embraced his redstone and used hia skills for evil he'd be a force to be reckoned with. I REALLY hope we see this in the future.

Scar in 15th huh? This didn’t age well. You should know from double life that Scar is an S-tier player

I think you should remake this video after secret life. A lot of members have been showing some crazy improvement so far, such as tango, scar, and ESPECIALLY Bdubs, bro managed to kill the Ender dragon and ended the session with 30 hearts still. Bro is a legend

I would argue Cleo goes much higher on this list, because of how strongly she swings into her social engineering abilities. she's said it herself, people seem to think she's so powerful they don't want to fight her. coupled with the fact she can lie and sniff out a lie with near certainty, I's say she deserves a higher placing

Now that Scar won Secret Life, and got a bunch of kills, I think his position needs to be updated

As I Joel fan, I actually don’t mind where u placed him despite what other ppl have said haha. He is incredibly risky and doesn’t ever rly get many allies(which is what makes his series so entertaining). However, saying Joel is decent at pvp is such an understatement. Quite easily the best Pvper by far but usually goes for the more “for fun” route.

Bro, you're gonna have to reevaluate your ranking system here. Scar is tied with Joel for second place in number of kills behind Grian. And he won Secret life. Scar is a goofball and everybody always underestimates him, but when he decides to take the gloves off, the dude has more than proven to be an absolute menace. All hail Scar for that glorious ending to secret life. 😂

GeminiTay is the true #1 member of the life series

Bro, Joel litteraly has the most kills in the entire series. He is TOP tier.

okay so I took the sum of each member's placements and divided by the sum of the number of players across the seasons in which they've participated to get a score reflecting their average placement. Lower score means better placement and here are the results. Note that I'm not claiming this represents skill, but the results certainly are interesting. The 4 winners are the top 4, which makes sense, and the best one who hasn't won one is impulse 1 Jimmy Solidarity 0.94 Mumbo Jumbo 0.89 Skizzleman 0.76 Lizzie LDShadowLady 0.71 TangoTek 0.59 Joel SmallishBeans 0.56 ZombieCleo 0.54 BdoubleO 0.54 Bigbst4tz 0.49 GoodTimesWithScar 0.47 Ethoslab 0.47 Rendog 0.44 ImpulseSV 0.41 Grian 0.27 Scott Smajor 0.22 Martyn InTheLittleWood 0.2 PearlescentMoon

“cleo may have been carried by martyn in dl” he pushed her off a cliff killing them both