The Rise and Fall of Lane's Band on Gilmore Girls

Lane was just done so dirty at the end of the show. She's a defiantly a big character but sometimes its like shes an afterthought in the show.

I think it was a mistake for Lane to get involved with Zach. Without that relationship, she could have used the band to get some exposure and move onto another group that was as driven as she was while the guys could have their low-key gig lifestyle.

I still wish if Lane HAD to end up with a band member, it would've been Brian, they always seemed the most complimentary and he took active interest in her family and was really supportive of her as a person

Gil and Brian are some of my favorite side characters

I rather imagine in my head that if Lane got famous, she would be somewhat similar to Mitski, but a Rock n' Roll Mitski

Gil 100% ❤ I love Lane and I have probably too much in common with her but now that I'm older I feel I prefer Gil perspective and attitude on things. And I love him on a meta level too, because it's so refreshing to see a guy like that in appearances seems to be a "fellow kids man" who ends up just really liking music and playing in a band. It's lovely ❤ And it's very nice to see a non conventional adult be responsible, mature and respectful for once.

I could be wrong, but to me the band represented Lane's strong desire for independence and she needed something to focus on to help her rebel and break free from the "shackles" of pressure her mom put on her. I know this has been pointed out before by others, but Lane seems to have almost a mirrored plot to Lorelei's when it comes to their upbringing. Only Lane doesn't come from a super rich family, but they both come from controlling families where the mother is the main source of control. I feel like Lane having a baby so young when she just wants to explore her independence further is very similar to Lorelei's problem. Though, they both have to embrace their responsibilities handed to them even though neither are probably ready for them. I also notice Lane is closer friends with Rory when Rory is close with her Mom and when Rory starts to gain a bit of independence from Lorelei, Lane is still there, but they still don't seem as close with each other. I feel like Rory becomes less understanding of Lorelei's problems the more she starts to gain favor with her grandparents. She feels less empathy for her Mom and when Lane has more freedom, doesn't seem to be around Lane as much. Personally, I respect both Lorelei and Lane's struggles with becoming independent people. It's hard to break that, especially if you do have a strong respect for family like they do seem to. I don't think either of them wanted to break their mother's hearts, but they needed to protect themselves and do what was right for them, by attempting to grow. For those that think Lorelei doesn't have a strong respect for family, I do think she does, or else you wouldn't see her doing all that she does for Rory. I think she wishes things were different with the relationship she has with her Mom and Dad, but she has to radically accept the reality of it. That's probably why she coddles Rory so much. She also protects Lane because she knows what she's going through.

Lane Kim deserved SO much more. It's not even I dislike Zach but like we barely got to see them as a couple have cute moments unlike Dave...we are just told Lane likes Zach and expected to believe it instead of making them have good chemistry so we can come to the conclusion as an audience without being told. As for her music career, the end may be realistic but Lane was SO devoted to music it just stings...If Lorelai could afford an Inn as a single Mum while paying for an Ivy League school then Lane should be on world tours and the cover of Rolling Stone!!

I also think Zack didn't like Gil due to jealousy, on the superficial level like you pointed out Gil is one of the prettiest people on the show I'm not even into blondes and I see it. Gil also because he's older has more experience with music, not only has he been playing longer he's seen and done things no one else has because they were too young or not even born yet. Gil has as the oldest and most experienced not to mention his knowledge and clear head has a very legitimate claim to be band leader. Zack is also confident but in a very insecure way while Gil is just confident, confident all these things combined is why I think Zack didn't like Gil at first. Also my mom who is into music says that as far as the bands go the music is slightly above average and has potential but more than anything else she said they're a personality band the kind of band that doesn't have the greatest music but has great personality and a really fun stage presence think Grateful Dead they're music is not amazing what made them amazing is that they built a whole culture WITHIN a culture!

My unpopular take is that Lane's ending is not sad at all. It's reality, a lot of us have dreams of making it big but the reality of fame is not great. I see Lane maturing and still having music in her life, but also having a family. I think that's a rich life; that's my life and the life of most of the population.

Honestly everyone but Zach. Brian is lovely (should have ended up with lane and I will die on this hill) Lane is driven and responsible Dave is diplomatic and kind. And Gil is just amazing in every way. He is gorgeous and I dare anyone to not smile when he is in a scene.

Gil and Brian were my favorite. Both are so sweet and have good vibes. They're both the type of guys I go for 😂 Also Lane is one of my favorite characters through the show. I rooted sooooo hard for Lane. I find the story arch of her and her mother to be sooo good because they took their time I love Lane and Zack's wedding episode. Mrs Kim's eventual acceptance and then full support of Lane was a wonderful journey.

Gil is my favorite and he was just such a fun addition to the show in general. I also just wanted to say how much I love your videos ❤ Between Gilmore girls and Buffy (my two favorite shows), your breakdowns are such a fun, insightful retrospective and I look forward to what you'll upload next! Thank you! ☺️

Zach is actually one of my least favorite characters on this show not only because he derailed Lane’s career and halted her development dead in its tracks, but he also derailed Hep Alien’s career. He pisses me off seriously. Lane settled for Zach instead of him truly being the love of her life, and that makes me sad.

If only Dave hadn't moved to the O.C. ☺️

There was so much I love about this video! My thoughts..I love music as much as Lane does.I think I'm (like) her! Dave was a wonderful first boyfriend for her. I love Sebastian and Gil both. I was very disappointed that Lane wasn't a successful musician like she wanted to be, instead involved with her mother's store. Again, great video!

Honestly, I would be curious to see how the band would evolve with the onset of new technology and Youtube. Plenty of musicians now are creating their own albums from home and posting them to the internet before they get famous or a record deal. I will say Lane does work as a good example on how priorities can change overtime and dreams can change as well. That said, I could see Lane get back into music once her kids have grown a bit. Based on your video, now I'm curious how a relationship between Brian and Lane would have gone down. Maybe the writer's decided to focus on Lane and Zach because they would have more drama due to their opposing personalities?

I wonder how you feel about the lane and brian ship. I see so many people root for those too. While I love Zach and Lane, I do get curious about what a relationship between lane and brian would be.

To be fair to Zach, I knew A LOT of guys like him when I was an arts major in college. Most of them mellowed out eventually. Which us not to excuse his bad behavior, but it's true to life. And Brian IS adorable! And so are his parents. They brought cartot sticks to the gig!

Off topic but pairing Lane with Zach seems so weird, even years after the show ended!! I think she would had been way better with Brian. He was sweet and kind and considerate.