Does -1/12 Protect Us From Infinity? - Numberphile

420,554
0
Published 2024-02-15
Ten years later... Professor Tony Padilla returns to the thorny issue of summing the integers arriving at -1/12. More links & stuff in full description below ↓↓↓

Also newly uploaded today about -1/12:    • The Return of -1/12 - Numberphile  

-1/12 shield sticker and t-shirts: numberphile.creator-spring.co...

Here's the new paper: arxiv.org/abs/2401.10981

Here are our -1/12 videos, including the one that started it all:    • -1/12  

Here's a blog Tony wrote about the original -1/12 videos: www.nottingham.ac.uk/~ppzap4/response.html

And here's a blog Brady directs people to when they message about the matter: www.bradyharanblog.com/blog/2015/1/11/this-blog-pr…

Interview with Terry Tao:    • The World's Best Mathematician (*) - ...  

Patreon: www.patreon.com/numberphile

Numberphile is supported by Jane Street. Learn more about them (and exciting career opportunities) at: bit.ly/numberphile-janestreet

We're also supported by the Simons Laufer Mathematical Sciences Institute (formerly MSRI): bit.ly/MSRINumberphile

Our thanks also to the Simons Foundation: www.simonsfoundation.org/

NUMBERPHILE
Website: www.numberphile.com/
Numberphile on Facebook: www.facebook.com/numberphile
Numberphile tweets: twitter.com/numberphile
Subscribe: bit.ly/Numberphile_Sub

Videos by Brady Haran

Numberphile T-Shirts and Merch: teespring.com/stores/numberphile

Brady's videos subreddit: www.reddit.com/r/BradyHaran/

Brady's latest videos across all channels: www.bradyharanblog.com/

Sign up for (occasional) emails: eepurl.com/YdjL9

All Comments (21)
  • @liliwheeler2204
    "I saw a tweet that made me so mad that I disproved it and wrote a paper about it" is the best way to do research
  • @atrumluminarium
    For what it's worth, the original -1/12 video is the reason I went on to study maths and physics in uni and here I am now 😂
  • @seifqiblawi4546
    You can genuinely feel Tony going "I told you so!" to everyone by the way he's talking. Man's been brooding for literally a decade
  • @dmitryrybin7831
    If you plot the graph f(N) = N(N+1)/2, it is a parabola that intersect X axis at points 0 and -1. The area bounded by parabola between 0 and -1 is exactly -1/12
  • @1104Tea
    Good lord have i really been watchng your videos for 10 years or more? Time sure flies by.
  • I was more or less mathematically illiterate and despised everything mathematics, and then I watched this video back in the day and it really intrigued me. Now, a few years later I am a grad student in pure mathematics, and it all started with watching these videos, particularly the one about -1/2! You can say what you want about the rigor of these computations, but for me, this is what started my love for mathematics!
  • @Mk-qk5bw
    One thing i love about numberphile is how passionate these very intelligent people are about such an awesome topic. Very nice change from the constant bombardment of low level nonsense. Thank you numberphile
  • @Kram1032
    C N² - 1/12 + O(1/N) such that C happens to be 0 makes way more sense than just a blanket -1/12. This is very cool
  • @maxtrax3258
    I have not seen Tony so excited for years. I like it. Good luck on his way
  • I was an undergraduate when the infamous -1/12 video came out and now I’m close to finish a PhD in arithmetic geometry. This made me feel so nostalgic.
  • @Examantel
    For those wondering why e^(-n/N)*cos(n/N) is so elegant, it's the fact that in C*N^2, C is the Mellin transform of the regulator function, which basically amounts to integrating x*e^(-x)*cos(x) from 0 to infinity, and it ends up being 0.
  • Man I love how Brady just goes in with the tough questions and points. Great video!
  • @Toobula
    Professor Padilla is a brilliant physicist and mathematician and incredibly skilled at explaining his thinking to us, even when ,like here, it gets into the realm of wonder. Thank you, Brady, for bringing him to us.
  • @Shaqfu283
    Ten years ago I was very unhappy with my career and watched the original video. I was so intrigued and inspired, I quit my job and went back to school for a math degree to better understand this result. I've never regretted this decision and seeing this video feels like everything has come full circle.
  • @RandoBox
    Lot more gray hairs on Tony. Cannot believe we have been growing up with this man for more than a decade. On a side note, any more of them big numbers?
  • @Vodboi
    Wow can't believe it's been 10 years since that video
  • @a52productions
    Your videos were one of the things that really got me into mathematics, and now I'm in graduate school for my physics PhD. Looking in the comments, I'm not alone in this either! Thanks for ten years of accessible math education -- even if some of it isnt entirely rigorous :p This sum regulation method is fascinating... I wouldnt buy putting an equals sign anywhere, but it's still extremely compelling that -1/12 is just as important here as it is via analytic continuation. Edit: That connection to physics -- wow! It makes me think that there must be some universally "preferred" method of renormalizing sums, some way that's "natural" in both mathematics and physics for reasons that arent entirely clear. I'm very curious why certain regularizations produce that behavior but not others...
  • @IllidanS4
    Oh my how the time has passed. 10 years ago I was in high school, watching these videos with astonishment and a genuine feel of adventure and love for all these awesome discoveries. A decade and two degrees later, and nothing has changed, except maybe for greying Professor Padilla, but still as enthusiastic as ever. Thank you, sincerely.