Shimano's XTR Chain Is Actually the BEST Bang for Your Buck!

26,587
0
Published 2024-03-17
Shimano's 12-speed chains are functionally identical to one another... at first. The XTR lasts twice as long as the Deore before reaching the 0.5% stretch mark. After this point you run the rist of damaging your cassette or chainring. The XTR also costs 2x as much as the Deore, but having to purchase and change your chain out half as often is worth a lot in my book. The $/mile value may be the same for both the XTR and the Deore, but the XTR gets my vote for best bang for the buck for the labor savings alone. The 10g weight savings just happens to be a (very small) side perk.

————————————————————————
🔗 Helpful Links

My Shimano 12-Speed Chain Comparison Guide - Complete with specs, product links, part numbers, etc. - There is also a tab listing out ‪@EMTBVideos‬ results with links to his videos.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1SXg6SI7aRCYZ3Pv6VO…

‪@EMTBVideos‬ Videos Chain Testing Videos:
Deore vs SLX:    • Shimano Deore vs SLX - 12 speed chain...  
SLX vs XT:    • Shimano XT vs SLX - 12 speed chain test   (The XT data from this one is incorrect. Watch the XT vs XTR video for an explanation)
XT vx XTR:    • Shimano 12 speed chain test - XTR vs ...  

My Shimano Crankset Comparison Video:    • Shimano's Deore Crankset is $477 CHEA...  
My Shimano Cassette Comparison Video:    • Shimano's $82 All-Steel Deore Cassett...  
My Shimano Shifter Comparison Video:    • Shimano Shifter Showdown | How is the...  
My Shimano Rear Derailleur Comparison Video:    • Deore to XTR for less than $25!! | Sh...  

————————————————————————
🚲 Product Links

Cranksets
Deore - amzn.to/3Pxh8N2 🥇Best Bang for Your Buck (Tied)
SLX - amzn.to/494nZEF + amzn.to/3PyBQfE 🥇 Best Bang for Your Buck (Tied)
Deore XT - amzn.to/43yzymk + amzn.to/4aqFuA7
XTR - amzn.to/3x6wqlR + amzn.to/3PICp6R

Chains
Deore - amzn.to/3uYSq1e
SLX - amzn.to/49Imehx
Deore XT - amzn.to/3PaSO3x
XTR - amzn.to/4c1Yl6h 🥇 Best Bang for Your Buck

Cassettes
Deore - amzn.to/3wqtno2 🥇Best Bang for Your Buck (Tied)
SLX - amzn.to/3wsZC67 🥇 Best Bang for Your Buck (Tied)
Deore XT - amzn.to/4bJ7Ua6
XTR - Check your LBS!

Shifters
Deore - amzn.to/47DdSXy
SLX - amzn.to/3uKO79n
Deore XT - amzn.to/3sYA27J🥇 Best Bang for Your Buck
XTR - amzn.to/438XxbS

Rear Derailleurs
Deore - amzn.to/3qKyAVl
SLX - amzn.to/45k4Ygy 🥇 Best Bang for Your Buck
Deore XT - amzn.to/3YLjFGY
XTR - amzn.to/3V2JK4l

Deore/SLX Pulley Set - amzn.to/3sdUd0v
XT Pulley Set - amzn.to/3si35SN (Can be used to upgrade Deore/SLX)

————————————————————————
📚 Chapters

00:00 - Opening
01:42 - Intro
02:07 - Specs & Pricing
07:51 - Conclusion
09:06 - Outro

————————————————————————
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/avbe/night-in-kyoto
License code: UEHYRQ

All Comments (21)
  • @Bikes-with-Ben
    If you all have mileage numbers you’ve hit before that 0.5% stretch, let me know! I’d love to collect some data!
  • @Juramentu
    A wise man changes his mind, thanks for the video!
  • @stefanodruetta
    I know it’s one person perspective: I’ve used deore, SLX and XT 12s chains on the same bike for the last 5 years, I could only get 6-700km out of deore and slx chains, but I get over 2000km on XT. Same transmission, same weather, same rider weight, pretty much. I also started using muc-off dry lube, dry brushing the chain after each ride and applying new lube, washing it once a month (I mostly ride in dry climate) and this seems to lengthen the chain lifespan. Where I live, XTR chains are double the price of XT, while XT is only a fraction more expensive than deore, so I don’t think I’ll try one any time soon. I’ve got a full SLX drivetrain, but derailleur pulleys, 10-45 cassette, and chain: these crucial components are in fact XT. And that’s where XT matters for real.
  • @adamthompson4979
    This has been a great series. I am going to check my chain RIGHT NOW! Thank you!
  • @Doc_Raphy
    I've been using the XT chain since last year. Been loving the shifting performance but I hate the fact that it's not very resilient against rust so I went back from using wet lube instead of chain wax lube. I've been trying to justify getting the XTR chain once my current XT chain wears out and I'm glad you uploaded this. I guess I now have two XTR components that I wouldn't mind getting, the calipers and the chain. 😂
  • @arthurgolubev
    Instant improvement since last video, keep it up! Thanks for the info, it really did answer to me why should I spend TWICE the price on supposedly The Same Chain But Lighter!
  • @BazenKazen
    Thank you for this video, these info are exactly what I need. I m going to change the chain and your infos are all I need to know about diferences among the chains :)
  • @cookie13spike
    Great overview, last week I put on a new XT chain and literally broke the plates three times in a few days, most likely a copy. Will give XTR a go from reputable dealer! cheers
  • I’ve been thinking about this after changing my original Deore chain last month. Got about 500 miles out of it before it was shifting poorly and stretched past .5. Going to try a more thorough lube/clean routine with the new one and see if that helps at all. If not I might make the jump to XTR… Looking forward to the rest of this series!
  • @nandor_books
    Nice video bro 👍, I'm following from the beginning and I'm so excited to see that final bike build
  • @jimm244
    A brake comparison will be challenging. There is a lot of subjectivity involved. I’ve used SLX & XT and have my own opinion. It will be interesting to watch your video when it comes out.
  • This is funny. They cheaped out on 12 speed chains compared to 11 speed… the only difference between the XT and XTR 11 speed were the hollow pins. If you ride in shit conditions, the XTR 12 speed is definitely the best one. The “brown” finish rusts quickly, the “gray” is also low grade. The “sil-Tec” is bombproof. How do I know? 4 years of Canadian winter commuting. Thanks for the video.
  • @dragoschisavu
    Nice video! Can’t wait for the brakes test. As of right now I really think deore 4 pot is best for the buck
  • @Damin216
    Awesome shirt! ;) Yesterday was closing day for the season at Ray's. Sad face!
  • @nyreppin1
    I believe it was on GCN where one of the pro team mechanics said if there's something you shouldn't cheap out on it should be the chain. Side note: if you wax your cn-9100 make sure you poke the wax out of the holes. A wire hanger works pretty good.
  • @keithcraig8270
    Nice job! Super informative discussion, Thank you! KC CA USA
  • @bradsanders6954
    Ive used XTR, Ive used Deore chains. And kept close track of mileage, both lasted exactly the same, one has hollow pins.
  • @markgarti3358
    I switched over to road and gravel bikes a few years back. I only use the the CN-HG901 XTR/DuraAce chains on our entire fleet. The chain is changed at exactly 1000 miles on every bike. Never an issue. Not sure though how that translates into MTB miles since I’ve been out of the realm for far too long.
  • @marekkrol5652
    Just looking at the tracker for my trail/enduro bike. XTR 864km, XT 1383km & current XT 1275km (and still going). Replacing between 0,5 & 0,75. Still on the first XTR cassette.