Was FNAF 4 intending it all to be a dream?

Published 2022-01-19
I hear a lot of people say that Scott Cawthon's original intent with FNAF4 was to say that the events of FNAF1-3 were all a dream, and I hear people defend Matpat's original theory to this day. This is a rebuttal to Matpat's video in particular, which holds a lot of common arguing points for Dream Theory.

Matpat's video    • Game Theory: FNAF, The Clue that SOLV...  

Other things used
FNaF 4 Menu Theme    • Five Nights at Freddy's 4 - Menu theme  
FNaF 4 Trailer    • Five Nights at Freddy's 4 Trailer  
FNaF 1 Gameplay    • Five Nights at Freddy's gameplay  
FNaF 4 Map www.reddit.com/r/fivenightsatfreddys/comments/meip…
FNaF 6 "Legal Woes" track    • Freddy Fazbear Pizzeria Simulator Sou...  

All Comments (6)
  • @spad_overolls
    The thing about dream theory is that its the most compelling narrative within the whole "Four games. One story." limitation. FNaF4 gameplay being from perspective of fnaf1 night guard just doesn't make sense within 4G1S. The reason why dream theory is so widely believed to have been true at least to some degree is because there's just too many little details, too many references. In the end, it seems to me that fnaf4 retroactively tried to pull towards a form of dream theory, while everything sister location onwards tries its hardest to walk away from that idea the box remained closed because the answer wouldve disappointed the community, and that definitely fits the bill for dream theory. i myself was always more of a fnaf3 ending truther, but tbh i've seen interpretations of dream theory that felt more satisfying than anything that fnaf lore had going for it after, and maybe that's why i have my own biases - most my problems with fnaf lore begun taking place when sister location happened and tried to overcorrect fnaf4
  • @chippedgoat
    Oh man this was a T R I P, I have not thought about dream theory in a long damn time, I think the fact that the lore has drifted away from that conclusion kinda proves to me that dream theroy probably was never truly intended.
  • @somebakedgood
    If we don’t play as the child during fnaf4 gameplay, then who are we playing as? We’re at head height with the doorknobs after all