The Red Dead Theories Iceberg

Maybe the true theory is the friends we made along the way

My opinion about when John gets arrested in Saint Denis is that if he was with the gang on the boat he would have most likely died when the boat sinks cause of the fact he can’t swim 🏊‍♀️

I love how there a dramatic fiery into that just says “BILL IS GAY” 💀

red harlow theory will always be funny since there’s a 10 year time gap between revolver and 2

So my gf works with ppl with tbi's The trolly accident could absolutely cause severe swelling and possibly bleeding. The loss of hosea and knowing he likely caused his gang to fail would only compound any symptoms. As well as the guilt of shooting that girl in the head. Yes he'd start loosing his grip on sanity

Personally, I like to think that after Red Dead Revolver, Red Harlow retired from the life of a Wild West gunslinger and lived a regular life. To rid himself of his past, Red changes his name to Leigh Johnson clears Armadillo of all the squatters and makes it livable again after the diseases we see in RDR2’s New Austin pass through, where the people elect him as Sheriff

We are ALL watching this iceberg lil bro 😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Aye bruh this quality is top tier I like how you didn’t just mention 50 different theories and actually went into depth with the most plausible and compelling ones

Of all the theories, I gotta say, I really hate the “Trelawny being The Strange Man” one with passion 😄

I think one of the main grounds for the strange man theory is that Arthur’s journal says that he saw someone similar in stature to trelawney in blackwater, and later trelawney says he was in blackwater. We also know from rdr1 that the strange man was in both blackwater and st. Denis.

Abigail being the rat is another stupid thing. People focus on one thing, but dont say the other… like her relationship with other gang members.. why would Abigail put Arthur, John, Hosea and Sadie into a danger? How she slipped away from bank robbery? - she isnt known outlaw, she was dressed up as a fancy lady of Saint Denis, she could easily mingle with a crowd. Or maybe Hosea helped her? Ever thought of that? They are each other’s father-daughter figures. He didnt want her to get captured or k*lled… Why was she taken by Pinkertons to van horn? - she literally says it. She was outside of a camp. And the reason no. 2.. STORY. PURPOSES ! Just so we have emotional scene of Arthur and Sadie telling her John’s dead. And mainly… SO SHE GIVES ARTHUR A KEY FROM THE CHEST, since John has told Arthur that Abigail knows where the money is. - Milton had no reason to lie about Micah… Milton counted on Arthur not leaving that fence store alive. So he could spill all the beans on him. And pls. Jack is John’s son. Point blank periodt. Javier joined a gang in 1895, Jack was born around spring/summer of 1895. Timeline doesnt add up. Bill is gay (Steve J. Palmer actually said it), Arthur was full of Mary in his head, and Dutch would’ve hardly sleep with her. Like… do you think he’d take an orphan girl in distress to his gang to use her as a prostitute? Really? 😂😂 that goes against the whole facade of morality dutch is preaching. Yes he said to john “oh we all had her” but after playing both games multiple times… it sounds more like he just wanted to tease john and make him mad.

I have to admit I was so focused on the content and information in this video I didn't realize 3 different voices narrated this video until after watching the whole thing. Good video, though!

I can believe Micah being a rat as early as that, given how despite all that running and hiding , Milton and the Pinkertons are always a step right behind. The only thing why I don’t think he would turn Dutch in that early (Colms set up) is because Micah still doesn’t have the location of the Blackwater money that only Dutch and MAYBE Hosea know the location of

I love commenting for waxys engagement and to boost him in the YouTube algorithm!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

“Our favorite rat” probably the best way to explain how people feel about Micah.

Uncle's exaggerated backstories are Red Harlow.

2:51 made me laugh so much

Im from the future and imma spoil the next 3 rockstar games for you. GTA6 reveals the man in the hat is actually rockstars version of the watchers. It assumed the role of angel of death in red dead 3 times(aka when dutch starts the van der linde gang) and reveals themselves in GTA 6 in a dlc update. In Bully 2 they make a cameo as the local groundskeeper AFTER clearing a certian mission

Abigail ain't a rat. Bill is super gay. Person ain't a rat. Jack is obviously johns son. I do agree that Molly may have been pregnant. Micah was already ratting on them in chap 3.

Been waiting for this one. Excellent video, as always!