We FINALLY Proved Why Ice Is Slippery

481,560
0
Published 2024-06-16
Why is Ice Slippery? New research suggests we finally have an answer.

Source article:
www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07427-8

0:00 Why is Ice Slippery?
1:14 The History of Understanding Ice
2:15 The Pressure Hypothesis
5:41 The Quasi-Liquid Layer Theory
6:50 The Results
10:17 Cold Ice Isn't Slippery

Merch!
I think Scientists are Rockstars so I made t-shirts to celebrate it
Einstein Rockstar Tee: www.drbenmiles.com/merch/p/rockstar-scientist-tee-…
Curie Rockstar Tee: www.drbenmiles.com/merch/p/rockstar-scientist-tee-…
Schrodinger Rockstar Tee: www.drbenmiles.com/merch/p/rockstar-scientist-schr…


If you enjoy the channel and want even more physics, tech, and business content, I've just launched new Instagram and Threads pages. Follow on the links below

Insta: www.instagram.com/drbenmiles
Threads: threads.net/drbenmiles
Newsletter drbenmiles.substack.com/

A few people have asked so I've added the info below. Some of these are affiliate links. If you make a purchase it doesn't cost you anything extra, but a percentage of the sale will help support this channel and my work to bringing entrepreneurship into science.
My camera : amzn.to/3ed5Xac
My lens: amzn.to/3xIAZyA
My lav: amzn.to/2SeE20Y and amzn.to/3nK33wA
My mic: amzn.to/3gUYYEv

All Comments (21)
  • It makes me wonder if these observations could inspire a "slippery" metal alloy that never needs lubrication
  • @flaym.
    Therapist: "double-bonded hydrogen isn't real, it can't hurt you" Double-bonded hydrogen: 6:25 (right side)
  • @antivanti
    As someone who lives "quite far north" I can attest to the fact that ice gets less slippery when it's REALLY cold. Bur also if the soles in your shoes are cheap and contain more plastic than rubber they get hard as bakelite and insanely slippery. Also if it's really cold and there's a slight layer of powder snow on perfectly blank ice you're screwed. There's no more slippery surface in the world. Literally no friction. It's like being the puck on an air hockey table 😅
  • @seanb3516
    I had a Chemistry Teacher demonstrate a Solid - Solid Chemical Reaction. It was quite odd looking. Two different white powders were placed in a glass tube. The tube is shaken only one toss at a time. In the tube blue crystals quickly formed. The crystals grew each toss of the tube but not otherwise. There had to be mechanical motion and contact.
  • @S1nwar
    do you know why, when you wet your fingers with a tiiiny amount of water you get insanely good grip (on a smooth metal surface for example)? completely dry fingers are slippery and completely wet ones too but theres that perfect amount of water that gives you an insane amount of friction
  • @Yezpahr
    Lol, the bloopers at the end were priceless. Here you are trying to prove something mundane that we all know happens and the ice gods just aren't letting you have it.
  • @bujin5455
    4:15. I don't know that I buy the idea that there are three square inches of ice skate on the ice when a person is in motion. (The area required for a 150lb person to be exerting 50psi.) I suspect the real expressed area is quite a bit less than that.
  • @pauljackson3491
    So the AFM is actually like a really small record player stylus. And with the laser bouncing off there are 2 levers involved: The stylus is one and the laser beam is the other.
  • @Min0rus
    This is just a meme compilation of people slipping on ice. You cant change my mind
  • @HallowedError
    This was fantastic and I remember all the old videos that basically said 'this is our best guess but it doesn't actually make sense' so this was really satisfying
  • @ralphc.644
    The "I" in ice Ih and Ic is the Roman numeral one. It should be pronounced "ice one h" and "ice one c". Fantastic video! Great work!
  • This is a perfect illustration of the problem with active measurement. The energy introduced to the system to measure it changes it. Therefore what you are measuring is the system plus the measuring method. So you can never measure just the system.
  • @uumlau
    Awesome video! The interesting thing is that the "it melts slightly under pressure" explanation was parroted as fact for so long. There's an old Feynman video (1986-ish) where he gives that explanation.
  • @MeriaDuck
    I knew about electron tunneling microscopes, this looks a slight bit simpler than that. The fact that we can scan atomic-scale resolution is mindblowingly fantastic.
  • The background baseline of "under pressure" and "ice ice baby" is just sublime when talking about vacuum @2:20.
  • @solii01
    I started watching this video with the thought "I will probably not understand this". But you explained everything very well. Good job and thank you!
  • @JohnDlugosz
    Two ice cubes fresh from the kitchen at -8 degrees C act more like proper solids and don't stick together when pressed. Interestingly, they also sound different when knocking against each other. However, they are still slippery, and if I drop one it will shoot off along the floor. Also note that in winter sports, a colder ice rink is "faster" for skating.
  • @MrTheoJ
    It is my understanding that wooden-shoes ( yes I'm Dutch ) are anti-slippery, the question ( if true ) is then why?
  • @gruffdavies
    Brilliant video. My favourite of yours so far (as a fellow PhD physicist, I really appreciate how much work you've put into researching this and loving the cheeky humour too. This new explanation of a classic phenomenon that we thought we understood reminded me of a fairly recent result showing that static electricity (e.g. amber and fur) isn't due to electrons as we thought, but molecular ions. Apparently, a chemist proved the electron model was energetically impossible. A bit embarrassing for us physicists, but I bet he was a physical chemist, so we can take the win anyway 😂). Keep up the great work, Dr. Ben!
  • @holderheck
    From what i have personally noticed below -34C i can't find anymore slippery ice.